If you're in the countryside around Boonville, NY, don’t miss the chance to satisfy your cravings at Luigi's Pizzeria, a beloved local gem nestled at 104 Water St. This charming pizzeria captures the heart of classic Italian-American cuisine, blending comfort and tradition right into each delicious bite.
Step inside, and you'll be welcomed by a warm, friendly atmosphere reminiscent of a cozy mom-and-pop establishment. The walls are lined with local memorabilia, and the inviting scent of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, instantly making you feel at home. Luigi's is not just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community hub where locals gather and share laughs over hearty meals.
Luigi's menu is a pizza lover's dream! Their signature pizzas boast a perfectly baked crust, with a rich, flavorful dough that's the result of time-honored techniques. Each pie can be adorned with an array of tantalizing toppings, making customization a breeze. One customer, Brian Parent, raves about the “flavorful dough” and “generous portions,” suggesting their pizzas are truly a gastronomic delight.
But the offerings don’t stop at pizza! Craving something different? Luigi’s also serves an impressive list of sandwiches and subs. You might want to try their Chicken Sandwich for a savory experience at just $7.00, or indulge in the classic Cheeseburger for only $5.75. The subs are equally noteworthy, with a selection that includes Roast Beef and Turkey, available in both small and large sizes to satisfy any appetite.
Side dishes such as the Fried Clams or Popcorn Chicken guarantee that you’ll leave fully satisfied. Or perhaps a helping of Blue Cheese Celery for a lighter touch? At a mere $1.00, it’s a steal with a delightful crunch! The value at Luigi's is something customers like Marty and Bonnie Yingling frequently highlight, proving that outstanding food doesn’t need to break the bank.
Attention to detail is also paramount here. Customers rave about the impeccable service, with staff members like AJ being praised for their hospitality and care, which enhances the overall dining experience. One reviewer, Christine Pierce, shared a moment where they received not only delicious wings but also outstanding customer service when addressed with a small error on their pizza order. It’s clear that at Luigi's, they genuinely care about their patrons.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Luigi's Pizzeria extends an invitation to come and experience their delicious dishes. With a menu that pleases all palates and an atmosphere that feels like family, every visit is sure to be memorable. Make it a point to stop by and discover why so many return to this beloved establishment year after year!
Your insights help other diners decide. We’ll keep your email private. Required fields are marked *
Marty
09/11/2025
Found this place last year, had to stop back this year! Seems like a little mom and pop place, but food was Great, service was really good! And price was perfect! As we are ,I noticed alot of local people getting take out! It's worth a visit if your in town! We will stop back next year!
Bonnie Yingling
26/10/2025
Food is always delicious Doesn't matter what you order. We live over three hours away and always make it a point to come here whenever we are anywhere near close!
Annie
18/10/2025
AJ is wonderful & did a great catering job for a reception @ The Hayloft. Loved the Riggies and my favorite was scalloped potatoes. Family visits when the can from out of state and they live their food!!! Chicken Parm, Big Hero & a pizza pie & mozzarella sticks to name 4. My lil sassy granddaughter got such a kick out of AJ
Brian Parent
04/09/2025
Luigi's Pizzeria ROCKS! The food is always perfect especially if you like a pizza with dough that has flavor to it and is perfectly cooked. Their toppings are delicious as well as their wings (boneless and regular). All of the portions are generous and whether a salad, sub or springtime Bullhead dinner always worth ordering for delivery or dining in. The service is polite and thoughtful always. My favorite thing is they deliver to us in Remsen. Sometimes we have to wait if they are busy but it beats driving 15 minutes there and back and the food always arrives perfect and delicious. Don't miss out on this great place to eat.
Christine Pierce
28/08/2025
Excellent food, and Customer service was over the top. My husband and I were heading up north to camp. We called ahead and stoped on our way to pick up pizza and wings. The pizza was slightly overcooked. The young lady at the counter apologized and said they would immediately make a new pizza. We were in a bit of a hurry and told her we would just take the other pizza. She asked for our address at camp and said someone would be behind us shortly to deliver it. We unpacked our vehicle, and had just sat down, when a vehicle pulled in our driveway. Our pizza was hot and delicious. Thanks again for bringing it out to us.
Philip White
20/08/2025
Pizza is all a matter of taste. Try it here and see if you like their take on it.